Rimowa vs Tumi – Selecting The Perfect Compact Case

Tumi and Rimowa are two prominent brands in the luggage industry, both known for their high-quality products. Tumi is well-regarded for its softside luggage, but it also offers aluminum hardside suitcases that rival those of Rimowa. The decision between these two brands often comes down to consumer preference for specific features and materials.

In this article, Rimowa vs Tumi will be compared based on criteria like durability, material choice, weight, size compatibility with major airlines, and their best suitcase models. This guide aims to provide a clear understanding of how each brand measures up.

A Brief Summary of Rimowa

Rimowa has a rich history, starting in Germany in 1898. Known for their signature aluminum luggage featuring distinct grooves, which were first introduced in 1950, Rimowa combines durability with iconic design. Initially a family-run business, it remained under original ownership until 2016 when it was acquired by LVMH (Louis Vuitton). This acquisition positioned Rimowa as the second-largest luggage manufacturer by sales, following Samsonite.

Today, Rimowa’s product lineup includes both aluminum and polycarbonate hardside luggage. Since partnering with Louis Vuitton, the brand has diversified to offer various travel accessories like backpacks, totes, slings, and phone cases. Their reputation for quality and innovative design continues to make them a standout in the luggage industry.

A Brief Summary of Tumi

Tumi, a well-established luggage brand from the United States, was founded in 1975. It gained recognition by creating robust ballistic nylon suitcases in dark shades, appealing to business travelers and airline crews. When Doughty Hanson & Co. acquired Tumi in 2004, the brand’s prices became more affordable, but this change affected the durability of their products, and the iconic lifetime warranty was discontinued.

In 2016, Samsonite took over Tumi, and the brand now makes up about 20% of Samsonite’s global sales. Tumi is known mainly for its softside luggage but also provides several hardside options, including aluminum models. These aluminum suitcases, while similar in style to those of Rimowa, are usually available at a lower price point.

Besides luggage, Tumi offers an assortment of backpacks, totes, duffels, and travel accessories, catering to a wide range of travel needs.

Key Differences Between Rimowa and Tumi

Rimowa vs Tumi: Design, Style, and Color Trends

When comparing Rimowa versus Tumi luggage, design aficionados will find distinct features that cater to different tastes. Rimowa is renowned for its sleek, minimalist aluminum designs, favored by travelers seeking a blend of durability and contemporary style. In contrast, Tumi offers a diverse range of designs from classic to modern, often incorporating advanced materials like ballistic nylon for lightweight yet robust options. Both brands offer a variety of colors to suit individual preferences, with Rimowa’s signature silver and matte black options appealing to those who prefer a timeless aesthetic, while Tumi’s vibrant choices cater to those seeking a pop of color in their travel gear.

Is Rimowa Lighter Than Tumi?

Rimowa’s suitcases are generally lighter than those from Tumi, though the difference is not drastic. Both brands create very heavy suitcases due to their use of premium materials, which are more durable but also add weight. Rimowa’s heaviest suitcase, the Rimowa Original Check-In L, weighs 13.7 lbs (6.2 kg). Tumi’s heaviest one, the Alpha 3 Extended Trip, weighs 17.9 lbs (8.11 kg). This makes a significant difference, especially for checked luggage, where weight limits are more forgiving. For carry-on and underseat luggage, the weight difference is minimal.

Is Rimowa More Durable Than Tumi?

Both Rimowa and Tumi produce highly durable suitcases. Rimowa often uses aluminum, which is durable and bends rather than breaks. They also produce polycarbonate suitcases, which are strong and flexible. For softside luggage, Tumi uses ballistic nylon, known for its strength. They also use materials like polycarbonate, aluminum, and a unique composite called Tegris for hardside luggage. Rimowa tends to use better materials for hardware, making their products slightly more durable. Reviews show that durability complaints for both brands are rare.

Which Brand Fits Airline Size Limits Better?

Rimowa and Tumi both design their suitcases to meet airline size restrictions. For carry-ons, Tumi’s dimensions are usually 22 x 14 x 9 inches, fitting American carriers. Rimowa’s are 21.7 x 15.8 x 7.9 inches, fitting European standards. For checked luggage, the maximum size allowed by most airlines is 62 linear inches. Neither brand typically exceeds this limit, though the Tumi Alpha 3 Extended Trip is an exception, exceeding the limit by 4 inches.

Budget-Friendly vs Luxury: Which Luggage Option Wins?

In terms of cost, Rimowa positions itself at the higher end of the luxury luggage spectrum, reflecting its premium materials and craftsmanship. This makes Rimowa ideal for travelers willing to invest in durability and design excellence. On the other hand, Tumi strikes a balance between luxury and accessibility, offering a wider range of price points that cater to different budgets without compromising on quality. This affordability factor, coupled with Tumi’s reputation for functional elegance, makes it a popular choice among frequent travelers and style-conscious individuals alike.

Which Brand Receives Better Reviews?

On average, Rimowa suitcases are rated 4.30 stars out of 5 on Amazon, whereas Tumi’s are rated 4.29 stars. Despite lower rankings compared to other brands, this result doesn’t necessarily indicate poor quality. Lower-priced items often receive better reviews due to lower expectations. The most common complaints for both brands involve customer service, color issues, and reduced packing capacity in newer models. Few reviews mention durability problems.

Do Tumi Suitcases Include More Features?

Tumi excels when it comes to added features. While Rimowa focuses on minimalism with TSA-approved locks and double spinner wheels, Tumi offers more. Tumi suitcases commonly have expandable zippers for 10-20% more capacity, USB ports, and an Omega closure system for secure zippers with replaceable heads. Tumi also utilizes antimicrobial linings to reduce odors in dirty laundry.

Which Brand Offers Better Value?

Determining the better value between Rimowa and Tumi depends on the features and durability you prioritize. Tumi often provides more features at a lower price, such as expanded packing capacity and smart features like USB ports. Rimowa focuses on durability and a sleek, minimalistic design. The overall better value will depend on individual preferences and what specific features or durability aspects are most critical to the buyer.

Warranty Terms: Rimowa vs Tumi

When comparing warranties, Rimowa generally offers a more straightforward and satisfying experience. Rimowa provides a five-year warranty covering defects in materials and workmanship. Tumi also offers a five-year warranty, but the first year covers everything, including damage caused by airlines, while the subsequent four years cover only manufacturing defects. Buyers often find Rimowa’s terms more favorable as they cover a wider range of issues, leading to a more comprehensive coverage over a longer period.

Should You Get a Suitcase From Rimowa vs Tumi?

known for their durability and high-quality materials. Their customer reviews reflect this reputation, showing that either brand will likely meet your needs for sturdy, long-lasting luggage.

• Cost: Tumi tends to be more affordable, with prices averaging 15% less than Rimowa. This price difference can be significant, especially for frequent travelers who need multiple pieces of luggage.
• Features: Tumi suitcases are loaded with practical features. These might include smart luggage tracking, USB ports for charging devices, and expandable compartments. Additionally, Tumi offers an unconditional warranty for the first year, which covers almost any defect.
• Weight: A notable downside of Tumi is its weight. Tumi suitcases are generally heavier than Rimowa’s, which can be a drawback for those who prioritize lightweight luggage. Rimowa, though not exceptionally light, tends to be easier to handle in comparison.
• Airline Compatibility: Tumi’s carry-on luggage is designed mainly for American airline restrictions. This could be a problem for travelers who frequently fly with European airlines, where sizes and weight restrictions can differ. Rimowa offers carry-ons that are better suited for European airline regulations.
• Brand Recognition: Rimowa has a distinctive, recognizable brand. For many travelers, the brand’s iconic groove design and reputation for luxury can be a significant draw. This visual appeal and brand prestige can influence the decision, especially for those who value aesthetics and status.
• Alternative: For those seeking a balance of price and quality, Briggs & Riley presents a compelling option. Their luggage, such as the Baseline carry-on, is just as durable as Rimowa or Tumi’s offerings. It’s also lighter, more affordable, and comes with an unconditional lifetime warranty. While they don’t offer aluminum options, their hardside models like the Sympatico are excellent choices.

Best Luggage From Rimowa and Tumi

Top Aluminum Suitcase From Rimowa: Classic

Why do we like it?

The Rimowa Classic is a standout aluminum suitcase, known for its durability and timeless design. Measuring 21.7 x 15.7 x 7.9 inches and weighing 10.1 pounds, it is crafted from 100% aluminum. Rimowa has also added polycarbonate wheels, full-grain leather handles, and a polyester interior. Its sturdy construction, which includes metal latches, TSA-approved locks, and metal attachments, makes it incredibly robust. Featuring four double spinner wheels, top and side handles, and a retractable handle, the Classic opens up in two equal parts with a fabric flex-divider to keep belongings organized. Although pricey, it offers longevity that justifies the cost.

Our Verdict

if you value timeless design, unmatched durability, and don’t mind investing in a premium product. The Rimowa Classic’s robust aluminum build and high-quality finishes like full-grain leather handles and sturdy polycarbonate wheels make it an excellent choice for frequent travelers looking for a luxury suitcase that can endure years of use. Its classic aesthetic also stands out, making it a statement piece. However, if weight and cost are significant concerns, you might want to consider lighter or more affordable options.

Top Aluminum Suitcase From Tumi: 19 Degree Aluminum Continental

Why do we like it?

The Tumi 19 Degree Aluminum Continental is another impressive piece, measuring 22 x 16 x 9 inches and weighing 11.8 pounds. Its frame is made of pure aluminum, but some elements use hard plastic instead of metal, like the handles and TSA-approved locks. Despite this, the suitcase is packed with features: a full fabric divider, a suit hanger, and Tumi’s unique 20-digit tracer code for locating lost luggage. Ideal for domestic flights, this suitcase offers exceptional durability and functionality, though its heavy weight is something to consider.

Our Verdict

if you seek a stylish, high-quality suitcase with a strong emphasis on functionality and security. The Tumi 19 Degree Aluminum Continental offers exceptional durability and practical features like a full fabric divider, suit hanger, and Tumi’s unique tracer code for added peace of mind. While it is slightly heavier and includes some plastic components, its overall performance and sophisticated design make it a great investment for those who frequently travel, especially domestically.

Top Hardside (Plastic) Suitcase From Rimowa: Essential

Why do we like it?

Rimowa’s Essential line caters to travelers looking for a lightweight yet sturdy option. This polycarbonate suitcase measures 21.65 x 15.35 x 9.06 inches and weighs 7.05 pounds. It offers flexibility and resistance to cracking, making it a long-lasting choice. The Essential line comes with plastic handles, a zipper, and one TSA-approved lock. Available in underseat, cabin, checked M, and checked L sizes, this suitcase combines durability with vibrant color options, appealing to both professional and casual travelers alike.

Our Verdict

if you desire a lightweight yet durable suitcase with modern features and vibrant color options. The Rimowa Essential’s polycarbonate construction provides flexibility and crack resistance, making it a reliable choice for various travel scenarios. Its sleek design, coupled with practical elements like plastic handles and TSA-approved lock, makes it suitable for both casual and professional travelers. If you need a suitcase that balances weight, style, and resilience, the Rimowa Essential is an excellent choice.

Top Hardside (Plastic) Suitcase From Tumi: Latitude

Why do we like it?

The Tumi Latitude is a premium choice for those seeking a lightweight, durable hardside suitcase. It measures 22 x 14 x 9 inches and weighs just 6.22 pounds. Made from high-quality polycarbonate, it is both sturdy and flexible. Designed to meet most airline size restrictions, especially for U.S. carriers, the Latitude is equipped with features like a fabric divider and multiple organizational pockets. The lightweight build ensures ease of handling and convenience during travel.

Our Verdict

if you want a lightweight, flexible, and durable hardside suitcase that complies with most airline size restrictions. The Tumi Latitude’s high-quality polycarbonate material and thoughtful design, including a fabric divider and multiple pockets, make it ideal for those who prefer ease of handling and organization. Its lightweight build significantly reduces travel fatigue, and its sturdy construction ensures longevity. It’s a fantastic option for travelers seeking convenience without compromising on quality or durability.

Top Softside Suitcase From Tumi: Alpha 3

Why do we like it?

For those who prefer softside luggage, the Tumi Alpha 3 stands out. Known for its robust nylon construction and thoughtful design, the Alpha 3 offers durability and ample storage. Featuring multiple compartments and organizational elements, it keeps belongings well-arranged. The suitcase is easy to maneuver, thanks to its smooth-rolling wheels and sturdy handles. Its balance of toughness and flexibility makes it a favorite among business travelers and frequent flyers.

By evaluating the best offerings from Rimowa and Tumi, travelers can make an informed choice based on their specific needs and preferences. From the solid aluminum build of the Rimowa Classic to the lightweight Tumi Latitude, each of these suitcases provides unique features and advantages, ensuring that there is a perfect match for every kind of traveler.

Our Verdict

if you prefer the versatility and expandability of softside luggage. The Tumi Alpha 3, with its robust ballistic nylon build and ample organizational features, is perfect for business travelers and frequent flyers who need flexibility and ease of access. Its smooth-rolling wheels and sturdy handles enhance maneuverability, and its balanced design provides both toughness and adaptability. If you’re looking for a reliable, spacious, and well-organized suitcase for diverse travel needs, the Tumi Alpha 3 is an excellent pick.

Related blogs:

Frequently Asked Question’s